6 replies to this topic

[Moonie Task]

What is your suggestion?: Add Elven SIgnet (Item acquired from Crystal Implings.) to the Collection log.

Is this in OSRS?: Yes

Has this suggestion been accepted already?: Naur

How would this benefit Alora?: More cloggers, more player retention, more time investment, more fun... (or less if people wanna target hunt for this useless item.)

[Mhk]

No support.
It would be pretty annoying and stupid to add something that has been ingame for years at this point and only spawns once on our one world every couple of hours.
Not only that, the item is literally useless on alora as nothing uses charges.

[Moonie Task]

No support.
It would be pretty annoying and stupid to add something that has been ingame for years at this point and only spawns once on our one world every couple of hours.
Not only that, the item is literally useless on alora as nothing uses charges.

Crystal Implings have a super boosted spawn rate in Alora, according to my own testing about 4-5 minutes between spawns.

Adding a Clog wouldn't hurt anything... specially when the item is already obtaintable.

Would the hunt for the clogger be annoying? Oh absolutely. Would it be nice to have that clogger? Also yes.

[Mhk]

Crystal Implings have a super boosted spawn rate in Alora, according to my own testing about 4-5 minutes between spawns.

Adding a Clog wouldn't hurt anything... specially when the item is already obtaintable.

Would the hunt for the clogger be annoying? Oh absolutely. Would it be nice to have that clogger? Also yes.

It’s one spawn for our one world server even if your “testing” is somewhat close to the real number. You realize hundreds of players are online at the same time, right?
Adding a clog for an item that has been in game for years does make players feel negatively about the update, that should be obvious, take the forestry changes for example.
It’s weird you’re speaking as if you have over 1000 clogs, kind of obvious due to the lack of support but your opinion that it would be good for the game is not in the majority.

[Moonie Task]

It’s one spawn for our one world server even if your “testing” is somewhat close to the real number. You realize hundreds of players are online at the same time, right?
Adding a clog for an item that has been in game for years does make players feel negatively about the update, that should be obvious, take the forestry changes for example.
It’s weird you’re speaking as if you have over 1000 clogs, kind of obvious due to the lack of support but your opinion that it would be good for the game is not in the majority.

Damn. Did you complain this hard when the Big Shark, Big Swordfish, Big Tuna were added? Or when the Steel Ring for Deranged Archaeologist was introduced to the game? 
Those are cloggers, that under your same arbitrary standards shouldn't be.

Lack of support? Yeah. People don't wanna grind this useless thing.

But none-the-less i do my due diligence to keep adding to the collection log. After all, what's the point of useless drops if not to be there as a clogger? Why did Alora add Brutus? More Clogs, More hits of copium dopamine.

[Mhk]

Damn. Did you complain this hard when the Big Shark, Big Swordfish, Big Tuna were added? Or when the Steel Ring for Deranged Archaeologist was introduced to the game? 
Those are cloggers, that under your same arbitrary standards shouldn't be.
 

Pointing out issues and calling out a bad suggestion = complaining? Whatever makes you feel better I guess.

I mentioned adding collection logs to existing content is not a popular or very wise decision but that isn't the only reason, If you actually read what I posted it's pretty clear there are multiple reasons as to why I'm saying no support.

 

But none-the-less i do my due diligence to keep adding to the collection log. After all, what's the point of useless drops if not to be there as a clogger? Why did Alora add Brutus? More Clogs, More hits of copium dopamine.

There's plenty of stuff in OSRS collection log that isn't in ours, I wouldn't say writing a 4 line suggestion with two full sentences to add stuff that no one wants / is different on alora is doing your 'due diligence'.

I'm fine with new content being added to the collection log, but why add something that's already been in the game since 2019, limited due to alora being one world, and the item doesn't even work properly on alora.

[Variant]

no support, anytime im in puro puro and see a crystal impling i catch it, and its been years and never got a single one. this tells me the rate is probably ass to begin wtih and like mhk says sharing that on 1 world with the time it takes to respawn anywhere in priff, yeah nthx