7 replies to this topic

[Radagon]

What is your suggestion?:

If you're not already aware, items purchased from the pk point shop are not added to your collection log. On the other hand, items purchased from the vote shop are added to your collection log. I'm suggesting we update the pk point shop to function like the vote shop. It would be a nice QoL update.

 

Is this in OSRS?:

N/A

 

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:

Nope!

 

How would this benefit Alora?:

Would be consistent with other shops on Alora. Would be a nice QoL change.

[H]

What items in particular are you thinking @Tbow loc

[Radagon]

What items in particular are you thinking @Tbow loc

All mystic items, enchanted robes, tomb of fire, and eternal glory. They're all a part of the collection log.

[Formula One]

If it’s for the sake of consistency - I’d rather see no items obtained from vote shop/pkp store to be added to the clog (unless it’s an item that you can’t obtain anywhere else other than the vote shop/pkp store.)

Mystic Variants - obtained through multiple slayer monster drops
Tome of fire - wintertodt
Enchanted robes - clues
Eternal Glory - Fountain of rune charging glories

Not trying to insult your intelligence as I know you understand where these come from, my point is those methods of acquiring said items would slowly become redundant and defeats the purpose if you can just make the item buyable through vote shop/pkp farming.
Perfect example would be the Infernal cape donation not counting towards clog/comp cape.

Long winded unnecessary explanation, in short - I’d say remove the clog unlocking from the vote shop to
Make it consistent with pkp store.

[Radagon]

If it’s for the sake of consistency - I’d rather see no items obtained from vote shop/pkp store to be added to the clog (unless it’s an item that you can’t obtain anywhere else other than the vote shop/pkp store.)

Mystic Variants - obtained through multiple slayer monster drops
Tome of fire - wintertodt
Enchanted robes - clues
Eternal Glory - Fountain of rune charging glories

Not trying to insult your intelligence as I know you understand where these come from, my point is those methods of acquiring said items would slowly become redundant and defeats the purpose if you can just make the item buyable through vote shop/pkp farming.
Perfect example would be the Infernal cape donation not counting towards clog/comp cape.

Long winded unnecessary explanation, in short - I’d say remove the clog unlocking from the vote shop to
Make it consistent with pkp store.

Given how long the vote shop has been functioning the way it does, it would only make sense (in my opinion) to change the pk shop to operate like the vote shop. By now, thousands of log slots have been filled via the vote shop. What's the point of changing that this far in. With that being said, I definitely see where you're coming from as well.

[H]

From a quick look at the vote shop, the only items that can be bought for collection log slots are untradeables/pets, while your suggestion is for tradeable items, plus it would take away from the grind for those items. No support.

[Radagon]

From a quick look at the vote shop, the only items that can be bought for collection log slots are untradeables/pets, while your suggestion is for tradeable items, plus it would take away from the grind for those items. No support.

On the contrary, 8 of the 13 ornament kits (which are tradeable) available on the vote shop will provide a collection log slot when purchased.

[Omicron]

These items were not obtained from their actual sources, and aren't meant to be obtained as collection log slots through the pkp shop, especially since that would make them buyable (through emblems).

Your suggestion has been declined, if you feel this was wrongfully done please contact a Forum Moderator+.