14 replies to this topic

[Mhk]

What is your suggestion?: 

Add impling jars to shop to the Hunting Expert in ;;shops

 

Is this in OSRS?: 

No

 

Has this suggestion been accepted already?: 

No

 

How would this benefit Alora?:

I'm suggesting specifically adding impling jars with clue scrolls as the reward, so Gourment (Easy), Eclectic (Medium), Ninja (Hard), and Dragon (Elite) jars to be sold at ;;shops for normies.

The reason being is it is much easier to buy these on the OSRS GE in massive quantities, these are basically never sold on the normie trading post.

Alora has already made it 'easy mode' for all game modes being able to spam lucky imps at puro puro, this would hopefully make puro puro a little less crowded and have people doing clues to complete the collection log like God intended.

[ykard]

Support,

 

seems fair, could also add to realism shop too in this case

[Variant]

no support, this is how players like Joe345 make gamble money. i think seeing implings in a shop = bad 

[Mhk]

no support, this is how players like Joe345 make gamble money. i think seeing implings in a shop = bad 

I could see how someone might make money on dragon imps, but Gourment, Eclectic & Ninja are traded so infrequently that I doubt it would impact anyone.

Elites are far more common for people to have just due to the nature of alora being endgame content focused anyways.

[HoldinAP]

Support, i did, i think made a one suggestion saying if it's possible to make like a trade at puro puro for dragon imps and luckie imps for explam, - trade 2 dragons imps for luckie imps? or luckie imps for dragons imps? - Cuz know on normie i at puro puro doing dragon imps more for people to actually be happy to see some jar's at trading post rather then, going to puro puro and hard working they fingers to get luckie and get clue scrolls, then they combine and boom master, then do hardest work go and complete every SINGLE clue log.

[Mack]

Support

 

It's commonplace for normal accounts on OSRS obtain their lower-tiered clue scrolls via impling jars, so I don't have an issue with that being the case here as well, so long as the cost reflects the convenience.

 

It's much less common for players to grind elite clues through Dragon impling jars due to the high cost, so those should be left out. Also, as you mentioned above, elites are most commonly received from late to end-game PVM, so that should remain the meta to incentivize players to do that content.

 

Based on current OSRS prices, these are the rough costs for clues through impling jars. These should be considered and adjusted for the Alora economy if this suggestion were to be implemented.

 

Gourmet: 1/25 rate for easy clues

On average, one would profit −12,257.00 to get an easy clue scroll from gourmet impling jars at current Grand Exchange prices, excluding the rewards from the completed Treasure Trails.

 

Eclectic: 1/25 rate for medium clues

On average, one would profit −35,029.50 to get a medium clue scroll from eclectic impling jars at current Grand Exchange prices, excluding the rewards from the completed Treasure Trails.

 

Ninja: 1/25 rate for hard clues

On average, one would profit −571,053.00 to get a hard clue scroll from ninja impling jars at current Grand Exchange prices, excluding the rewards from the completed Treasure Trails.

 

Dragon: 1/50 rate for elite clues

On average, one would profit −12,661,194 coins to get an elite clue scroll from dragon impling jars at current Grand Exchange prices, excluding the rewards from the completed Treasure Trails.

[Variant]

I could see how someone might make money on dragon imps, but Gourment, Eclectic & Ninja are traded so infrequently that I doubt it would impact anyone.

Elites are far more common for people to have just due to the nature of alora being endgame content focused anyways.

at that point just put the clue in the shop and skip the step of putting implings and scale the price accordingly. buying clues regardless seems dumb to me, clue rates are already so fast on here you can get 50 mediums an hr at the stone chest and 110 easys an hr at ham members

[Mhk]

at that point just put the clue in the shop and skip the step of putting implings and scale the price accordingly.

It doesn’t really matter to me, the main point of the suggestion is that normal accounts on OSRS basically have an infinite supply. The clues coming from the impling jars is just more in line with OSRS.

buying clues regardless seems dumb to me, clue rates are already so fast on here you can get 50 mediums an hr at the stone chest and 110 easys an hr at ham members

I’m sure myself and many other normal accounts would like to do other content rather than grinding clues that I could just buy if I was playing OSRS. I don’t think normal accounts should be forced to collect low level clues like an iron because Aloras eco isn’t as active as OSRS.

[Variant]

It doesn’t really matter to me, the main point of the suggestion is that normal accounts on OSRS basically have an infinite supply. The clues coming from the impling jars is just more in line with OSRS.

I’m sure myself and many other normal accounts would like to do other content rather than grinding clues that I could just buy if I was playing OSRS. I don’t think normal accounts should be forced to collect low level clues like an iron because Aloras eco isn’t as active as OSRS.

there's a lot of things alora doesnt have in line with osrs, including being able to instantly sell all loot to a grandexchange, vs our tp system can take long you can easily be undercut and theres no infinite supply of buyers/sellers for any item you want. that doesnt mean we add a insta buy/sell option to the tp. i see this similar to this suggestion, not everything can/should be 100% like osrs, part of the clogging process is gaining some stuff yourself, even as a normie it shouldnt ALL be p2w. most players on osrs cant even afford to just buy mass implings for clue openings

[Hard Dance]

Support from me, even tho i suggested something similiar ages ago but it was declined and i can see why, however if we could scale the prices to make some sense and people couldnt abuse the loot from imps im down for some kind of imp shop, or maybe it could have limited stock of imps per day or something.

[Mhk]

Variant, on 26 Jan 2026 - 10:31 PM, said:
there's a lot of things alora doesnt have in line with osrs, including being able to instantly sell all loot to a grandexchange, vs our tp system can take long you can easily be undercut and theres no infinite supply of buyers/sellers for any item you want. that doesnt mean we add a insta buy/sell option to the tp.

I mean there is already an alora specific feature that will instantly buy specific items to boost TP activity called the item consumer, while it might not buy everything, it does assist in helping normal accounts have a better experience by having items not sit for weeks at a time.
Instead of taking items out of the game though, this would be a gold sink to supplement items that are lacking in our smaller eco.

 

Variant, on 26 Jan 2026 - 10:31 PM, said:
i see this similar to this suggestion, not everything can/should be 100% like osrs, part of the clogging process is gaining some stuff yourself, even as a normie it shouldnt ALL be p2w. most players on osrs cant even afford to just buy mass implings for clue openings

I would agree with you if all game modes couldn't cheese the easy / medium clogs already by just spamming lucky imps at the 'Alora' puro puro (& hard / elite clogs aswell since the latest update a couple months ago).
It's kind of a stretch to say people who complete the easy / medium clogs like this really earned it themselves since it cuts several hundred hours out of the clue grind, unless you get unlucky like @Logan, people would still have to do clues, this would just take the ironman grind out for accounts that don't want to be ironman.

[Variant]

I mean there is already an alora specific feature that will instantly buy specific items to boost TP activity called the item consumer, while it might not buy everything, it does assist in helping normal accounts have a better experience by having items not sit for weeks at a time.
Instead of taking items out of the game though, this would be a gold sink to supplement items that are lacking in our smaller eco.

 

I would agree with you if all game modes couldn't cheese the easy / medium clogs already by just spamming lucky imps at the 'Alora' puro puro (& hard / elite clogs aswell since the latest update a couple months ago).
It's kind of a stretch to say people who complete the easy / medium clogs like this really earned it themselves since it cuts several hundred hours out of the clue grind, unless you get unlucky like @Logan, people would still have to do clues, this would just take the ironman grind out for accounts that don't want to be ironman.

if youve done puro puro it actually isnt just a cheese completion at luckies, especially when 1 or 2 people there with you reduces the luckies per hr significantly. i mean we can agree to disagree on this topic, still no support, implings in a shop just looks silly imo

[Mhk]

if youve done puro puro it actually isnt just a cheese completion at luckies, especially when 1 or 2 people there with you reduces the luckies per hr significantly

I mean I’ve almost green logged easy and medium clogs and I’m not even over 1k lucky imp kc, it definitely is the easier route lol.

implings in a shop just looks silly imo

I think it looks more silly to have the meta for clue collection logs be something other than clues :shrug:
Being able to spam lucky imps or Sherlock note clue steps is more weird to me than buying impling jars like I can on OSRS.

[Solo Rat]

I'm not opposed to being able to buy clues/implings but i'd be more open to having these bought with things other than GP. 

 

I'd like to see them in loyalty point shop/daily point store for all modes and at a fair price to stop them from just being abused - not that 3a has much weight on this server, but an influx of clues would definitely drop the prices. Agree with your point on Sherlocks being a bit odd as it removes the "fun" (or what they intended to be fun) of completing the clue.

 

Nonetheless, support for a way that's not just thieving HAM members for easy clues or stone chests for mediums

[Omicron]

Your suggestion has been declined, if you feel this was wrongfully done please contact a Senior Moderator+.