Thank you for doing the math and breakdown
Feels like every time I do the math, someone comes around with...
"Alan stop complaining and trying to make the game easier"
"some pets are meant to be rare"
"its all rng. you get it or you don't. stop crying"
"we shouldn't make things easier than OSRS"
"you're devaluing the work of people who already have pets"
"the tp prices will blah blah blah"
"you can afk it though"
"there's no imbalance here"
So I'm just going to say it first
@Itachi laid everything out for you.
Look at the numbers and decide how much effort you would be willing to put in for the reward.
We don't need to be exactly like OSRS.
We need our drop rates to be convincing enough for RSPS players to want to invest their time for a chance at the reward.
That's what will keep this game fun and convince players to keep coming back.
No problem, 1/128 just looks good, but averaging the pet to 1 in 1k master clues would be fair too imo, so 1,000/15 is roughly 67 mimics, so 1/67 (although it looks small) is imo still plenty fair, but we'll see what Omi responds