10 replies to this topic

[I carry her]

What is your suggestion?: 

• Under the other category in the collection log add a "Vote" section with everything you can obtain from voting.
• Under the other category in the collection log add a "Crystal Chest" section with everything you can obtain from crystal keys.
• In the "Miscellaneous section or a new section "Wilderness" add the obtainable PvP weapons and armours you can obtain from wilderness npcs.
• Add the house, herbi and phoenix to the skilling pets section, they are in the all pets section already.
• Change the clue rewards in the collection log to match Alora's clue rewards tables.
• Under the other category in the collection log add a "Forums" section with everything you can obtain from posting on the forums.

 

Is this in OSRS?:

The collection log is but these extra additions would be to match Alora's content.

 

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:

No

 

How would this benefit Alora?:

Would add more to the collection log for people to complete. It would also help people know everything obtainable from the crystal key chest.

[Dylain]

100% support without a doubt. As your suggestion states, it would add more of an incentive and not only that, but provide more of a reason for dedicated users to complete the Collection log. I'm all for new challenges that present themselves.

 

We could also implement some-sort of reward for players that have collected every item existing through-out the Collection Log, if that was something the staff-team would open too. But apart from my two cents, great over-all suggestions @ I carry her .

[GroupIronman]

Yeah I support the idea to add to collection log

[22]

A decent list of suggestions, so support all of them.

[Dante]

Very well-written suggestions and kudos to you for being the 1% (people who actually follow the form when posting suggestions)!

 

I have to say these are all great ideas and I don't see any harm in adding any of these to the collection log. Support.

[Mullyyy]

support from me, i actually enjoy seeing my accomplishments. 

 

but first i'd like to see the current collection log working before adding more lol.

[Shawn TM]

• Under the other category in the collection log add a "Vote" section with everything you can obtain from voting.

--> This suggestion gets a no support from me. People can just buy vote books and get the items like that. Which makes this a buyable achievement on the collection log (something I don't want to be on there)

• Under the other category in the collection log add a "Crystal Chest" section with everything you can obtain from crystal keys.

--> Same goes for this suggestions ( No support). Again a buyable achievement.

• In the "Miscellaneous section or a new section "Wilderness" add the obtainable PvP weapons and armours you can obtain from wilderness npcs.

---> Support on this one. Great addition.

• Add the house, herbi and phoenix to the skilling pets section, they are in the all pets section already.

--> Support, not sure why they are in the misq section.

• Change the clue rewards in the collection log to match Alora's clue rewards tables.

---> Big support here!

[I carry her]

 

• Under the other category in the collection log add a "Vote" section with everything you can obtain from voting.

--> This suggestion gets a no support from me. People can just buy vote books and get the items like that. Which makes this a buyable achievement on the collection log (something I don't want to be on there)

• Under the other category in the collection log add a "Crystal Chest" section with everything you can obtain from crystal keys.

--> Same goes for this suggestions ( No support). Again a buyable achievement.

 

I suppose you do have a point on these, on certain game modes these collection logs would just be purchasable.. Whether or not this makes me feel differently on having them in the collection log, I'm sure sure. While I guess you could donate to complete a couple of the collection logs anyway, (Inferno, etc, certain pets can be donated for) would having a couple sections in which normal modes could buy their way through it be much of a big thing. As there's no rewards for completing a collection log, it's just a personal thing so someone else having an advantage shouldn't effect anything.

 

We could also implement some-sort of reward for players that have collected every item existing through-out the Collection Log, if that was something the staff-team would open too. But apart from my two cents, great over-all suggestions @ I carry her .

 

A great idea, although I'm not sure what sort of reward could be given. Possibly a forum award could be created for anyone who's fully completed their collection logs, maybe an announcement for when someone's completed all of their log as well, just like when someone hits a level 99 or so could work perhaps. :)

 

Then I guess what Shawn mentioned might come into play, if there was some sort of reward would people want a couple sections which you could buy your way through on a normal mode, hmm.

[Zach McCoy]

I love this suggestion. I’m a completionist/achievement type of player so something like this would be extremely helpful, 100% support.

[MT]

Would like to see some, if not all, of these suggestions added into the collector’s log. A forum award would be nice, too.

[Ultistic]

Your suggestion has been declined, if you feel this was wrongfully done please contact a Forum Moderator+.