Jerbear

Receiving the GOTR pet on the last roll during event, greening the log and getting the prize!

Excited to keep being a part of this community, and help it grow further! 9 years is a long time, but not long enough!

What is your suggestion?:

TL;DR: Add a roll for Smithers Pet when smelting bars

Currently the Smithers pet has a chance to be obtained in the following circumstances, each with equal likelihood:

1. Superheating

2. Motherlode Mine Strut Fixing

3. Crystal Bowl Crafting

4. Giants Foundry Sword Turn-in

5. Blast Furnace Bar Creation

6. Cannonball Moulding

7. Smithing on an anvil

This leaves a pretty obvious gap — smelting bars. 

As this is a common mechanism for training the skill, there should be a chance to receive the pet when smelting bars on a normal furnace. 

Is this in OSRS?:

No, but neither is the pet!

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:

Not that I've seen. Also not a bug as it was the intended behaviour

How would this benefit Alora?:

Players can receive the pet through one of the skill's main training methods, and one they'd likely expect a chance to receive it from

What is your suggestion?:

Make the Vale Totems roll a chance for the House Pet, as you earn Construction experience when building them

Is this in OSRS?:

No, but then again neither is the House Pet!

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:

Nope

How would this benefit Alora?:

Provides another avenue for obtaining the pet not locked behind expensive supplies, and brings more incentive to a sweet piece of content!

What is your suggestion?:

Allow us to use noted bowstrings to fill the new spool

Is this in OSRS?:

Yes, see the wiki here

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:

Not that I've seen

How would this benefit Alora?:

Makes the spool behave as expected, reducing the time needed to load it up

What is your suggestion?:

Currently, Phoenix colour changes cost 250 firelights, but are one-time use; if you swap to something else, the colour is lost. It should be a permanent unlock like recolour for heron, giant squirrel, etc.

Is this in OSRS?:

Yes; per the wiki, it's a one-time fee

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:

Not that I've seen

How would this benefit Alora?:

Let's players match their Phoenix pet to their outfits, aligns properly with OSRS

What is your suggestion?: Add a button to deposit all clue items from inventory into your POH storage

Is this in OSRS?: Uncertain. Couldn't find info on wiki

Has this suggestion been accepted already?: Not that I've seen

How would this benefit Alora?: Currently you have to select each tier of clue individually, then deposit the items for that tier. It'd be a lot easier to have an option on the treasure chest itself to deposit all, so you don't have to go through each individually

Excited for this, and wild it's been 8 years of uptime! Congratulations and thanks to all those who have made it possible to run so long

What is your suggestion?:

It would be nice (if possible) to wield imcando hammer in the off-hand slot. This would allow for dual-wielding it with the crystal and amy's saws for fashionable attire.

Is this in OSRS?:

Nope

As pointed out by @Formula One, this is available on OSRS! Thank you :) https://oldschool.ru...mmer_(off-hand)

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:

Not that I've seen!

How would this benefit Alora?:

Fashionscape

It's guaranteed 1 per lap at Ardy if you have the elite diaries done. Agree with other responders, this doesn't need a rework

What is your suggestion?:
Like with pieces of the pyromancer outfit, allow players to trade in spare hunter guild outfit pieces for another loot sack. Could scale which sack with the player's hunter level (e.g. you receive the master sack if you're qualified to receive master tasks)

Is this in OSRS?:
No

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:
Not that I've seen

How would this benefit Alora?:
Allows players to benefit from an otherwise purposeless duplicate item

On OSRS there is an overall limit of 1200 pts per game. This would be effectively setting the limit at 2200 (1100 per type). So yes, it's going to differ from OSRSO, but that seems like just an improvement. Don't think there's a need to precisely match OSRS for everything when we can make it better for the players here.

What is your suggestion?:

Remove the limit on overall points from Guardians of the Rift, but keep the individual for elemental and catalytic

Is this in OSRS?:

No, they limit to 1200

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:

Not that I found

How would this benefit Alora?:

We already have limits at 1100 points on each individual energy. Limiting overall just frustrates as you can lose hundreds of charges when putting in all at once if your elemental or catalytic separately breaches the limit. Why not just have the cap on each separately? Otherwise we have to play to be less efficient, which just feels dumb.

What is your suggestion?: 

Add a one-time, 500K payment to permanently unlock falconry

Is this in OSRS?:

Yes. See here

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:

Not that I've seen

How would this benefit Alora?:

With the introduction of rumours, falconry is much more commonly needed. It sucks to have to pay every time you go, especially when OSRS has a way to not need to.