Jump to content


Photo

Grotesque Guardians Quality of Life



  • This topic is locked This topic is locked
12 replies to this topic

Posted 20 July 2022 - 09:30 PM #1

Real Alan

Realism

Real Alan
Posts: 817
Likes: 1,111
Clan: Realists



  • Member since:
    07 Jun 2019

    • Time spent:
      72d 47m 19s

  • Total level:
    2,277
    Awards

What is your suggestion?:

 

Options:

a) Prevent Dusk from spamming his prison special attack consecutively 

b ) Allow players to continue attacking Dusk after moving out of the prison (similar to bloat in TOB)

c) Reduce the animation stall time

 

 

Side note - Jar should be more rare than pet.

Here's what OSRS has listed

cf9ba9e6cf62dd01128bec3c2f2f54b8.png

3567a1b79218f58926c05bff1dfeda19.png

Could you clarify if you get 2 rolls at pet per kill (1 for Dawn kill & 1 for Dusk kill) or just 1 roll per completion.

 

Is this in OSRS?:

No

 

Has this suggestion been accepted already?:

No

 

 

How would this benefit Alora?:

Would make grotesque guardians less annoying to slay.

 

Problems with the current system...

1. There's too much downtime spent waiting for Dusk's special attack (prison) to run its course (~10 seconds every time)

2. If Dusks spams the special attack consecutively, you end up with a 1-tick attack window (0.6s), followed by 10 seconds of waiting just to get in each additional hit 

3. There is a long animation before the 2nd half of the Dusk fight takes place (unattackable) -> attack window -> 10s special attack

This makes it easy to miss the window (like if you're on food/pot/weapon delay) and greatly reduces the player's dps.

 

timon-let-me-at-em.gif


rCjd36m.gif

779858f92372b65448411ebb99ae2454.gif

Community Awards

186389e1c9f184e3f3b56b038179afd0.png

 

Spoiler

Content

467021453b22f2e55b6161e34fc517a3.png

Topic 89500 - My Problem with Staff

Topic 89503 - My Problem with Staff II

Topic 89512 - My Problem with Staff III

Accomplishments

b238e051c524997fa395f7b94120f707.png

17f0b0f3326931f82ad4b16c654cbca8.png

ed4359218fa2f48adc03ffb7aabeb9ce.png

f0db828700bca6a0f649a8675bd8d2ff.png

Spoiler

Game Suggestions

Pet Timeline

4053bef497bbaee8b3db94aec03237ed.png

Spoiler

Posted 20 July 2022 - 09:36 PM #2

Formula One

Veteran

Formula One
Posts: 532
Likes: 512
Clan: Paragon
Location: Aus



  • Member since:
    07 Jan 2019

    • Time spent:
      50d 20h 39m 9s

  • Previous username:
    4AGE

  • Total level:
    2,277
    Awards

SUPPORT

 

The annoyance of Dusk's consecutive special attack makes it fairly off-putting. Timings can easily be extended by 30-45seconds due to b2b2b Prison attacks.


classic_large.pngEliteSR20   hcim.pngToto Wolff   gim.pngCarl Gustav   uim.pngTraction Off   eim.pngPerson 5

Beginning of Main account  -  Link to the challenge

1281b24e8b6447295abd4cdac05ab33d.png

7d67178fd306417ea65c108e9a6660d4.png
b864bba6cdd33bb25fd298f8dbe481d8.png

33e2935f80c933d281ed7b5b752da131.jpg

formula.pngunknown.png

 


Posted 21 July 2022 - 12:29 AM #3

Selenagomez

Veteran

Selenagomez
Posts: 534
Likes: 606
Clan: Paragon #FAFO



  • Member since:
    25 Jun 2020

    • Time spent:
      65d 21h 49m 41s

  • Previous username:
    Run IT BACK

  • Total level:
    2,277
    Awards
I havent done ggs in quite some time. But when I did do them I dont remember this being an issue. If it's common for him to be spamming his special and you are basically unable to attack then yes this should be changed. But if it's just an occurence maybe 1/5 kills that he will use the attack twice on your then no it shouldnt be changed. Especially if it's like osrs (which you said it is by saying these changes are not in osrs)
Posted Image
Posted Image

Posted 21 July 2022 - 01:09 AM #4

Real Alan

Realism

Real Alan
Posts: 817
Likes: 1,111
Clan: Realists



  • Member since:
    07 Jun 2019

    • Time spent:
      72d 47m 19s

  • Total level:
    2,277
    Awards

I havent done ggs in quite some time. But when I did do them I dont remember this being an issue. If it's common for him to be spamming his special and you are basically unable to attack then yes this should be changed. But if it's just an occurence maybe 1/5 kills that he will use the attack twice on your then no it shouldnt be changed. Especially if it's like osrs (which you said it is by saying these changes are not in osrs)

 

 

I suggest you try Grotesque Guardians out on Alora, my friend.

 

Then come back with feedback on what you think is best for our community, not OSRS. 

 

Personally, I did 420 kills with max gear and nh gear (as practice), and I found it super slow, inconsistent, and unpleasant to do.  

 

2dc9f97131e4ad87b9774ea27d186539.png

 

Note: I have never tried them on OSRS


rCjd36m.gif

779858f92372b65448411ebb99ae2454.gif

Community Awards

186389e1c9f184e3f3b56b038179afd0.png

 

Spoiler

Content

467021453b22f2e55b6161e34fc517a3.png

Topic 89500 - My Problem with Staff

Topic 89503 - My Problem with Staff II

Topic 89512 - My Problem with Staff III

Accomplishments

b238e051c524997fa395f7b94120f707.png

17f0b0f3326931f82ad4b16c654cbca8.png

ed4359218fa2f48adc03ffb7aabeb9ce.png

f0db828700bca6a0f649a8675bd8d2ff.png

Spoiler

Game Suggestions

Pet Timeline

4053bef497bbaee8b3db94aec03237ed.png

Spoiler

Posted 21 July 2022 - 08:52 AM #5

Selenagomez

Veteran

Selenagomez
Posts: 534
Likes: 606
Clan: Paragon #FAFO



  • Member since:
    25 Jun 2020

    • Time spent:
      65d 21h 49m 41s

  • Previous username:
    Run IT BACK

  • Total level:
    2,277
    Awards

626Ds0y.png

 

idk i did it in void gear. He didnt spam his prison attack, he did it one time when i killed the first one and maybe 10-20 seconds later then he was dead. 


Posted Image
Posted Image

Posted 21 July 2022 - 09:53 AM #6

Real Alan

Realism

Real Alan
Posts: 817
Likes: 1,111
Clan: Realists



  • Member since:
    07 Jun 2019

    • Time spent:
      72d 47m 19s

  • Total level:
    2,277
    Awards

Keep going!  The first kill is quick if you dump c hally specs.   Afterwards, it just gets more and more annoying. 

Takes you 1 second to avoid the prison attack and 9 seconds to wait for the animation to end. 

Some kills go smoothly.  Other kills just drag on and on. 

In my opinion, all the waiting around prevents me from flowing and enjoying the activity.

Speedruns are super RNG dependent.  You can have the smoothest Dawn fight, but if Dusk wants to spam special attacks, all your effort goes to waste.

 

Here's my logic...

 

Gargoyle : Dusk&Dawn :: Cave Kraken : Kraken Boss

Keep in mind, gargoyles are level 75 slayer monsters, while kraken are level 87 slayer monsters.

 

If Alora is ok with a simplified kraken boss, I don't see why we can't have a less annoying Dusk & Dawn.


rCjd36m.gif

779858f92372b65448411ebb99ae2454.gif

Community Awards

186389e1c9f184e3f3b56b038179afd0.png

 

Spoiler

Content

467021453b22f2e55b6161e34fc517a3.png

Topic 89500 - My Problem with Staff

Topic 89503 - My Problem with Staff II

Topic 89512 - My Problem with Staff III

Accomplishments

b238e051c524997fa395f7b94120f707.png

17f0b0f3326931f82ad4b16c654cbca8.png

ed4359218fa2f48adc03ffb7aabeb9ce.png

f0db828700bca6a0f649a8675bd8d2ff.png

Spoiler

Game Suggestions

Pet Timeline

4053bef497bbaee8b3db94aec03237ed.png

Spoiler

Posted 21 July 2022 - 10:00 AM #7

Selenagomez

Veteran

Selenagomez
Posts: 534
Likes: 606
Clan: Paragon #FAFO



  • Member since:
    25 Jun 2020

    • Time spent:
      65d 21h 49m 41s

  • Previous username:
    Run IT BACK

  • Total level:
    2,277
    Awards

Keep going!  The first kill is quick if you dump c hally specs.   Afterwards, it just gets more and more annoying. 

Takes you 1 second to avoid the prison attack and 9 seconds to wait for the animation to end. 

Some kills go smoothly.  Other kills just drag on and on. 

In my opinion, all the waiting around prevents me from flowing and enjoying the activity.

Speedruns are super RNG dependent.  You can have the smoothest Dawn fight, but if Dusk wants to be spam special attacks, all your effort goes to waste.

 

Here's my logic...

 

Gargoyle : Dusk&Dawn :: Cave Kraken : Kraken Boss

Keep in mind, gargoyles are level 75 slayer monsters, while kraken are level 87 slayer monsters.

 

If Alora is ok with a simplified kraken boss, I don't see why we can't have a less annoying Dusk & Dawn.

what is simplified of kraken? Kraken here is harder than it is on osrs. On OSRS you do not need to protect mage AND eat you just need to eat on osrs.


Posted Image
Posted Image

Posted 21 July 2022 - 01:14 PM #8

Real Alan

Realism

Real Alan
Posts: 817
Likes: 1,111
Clan: Realists



  • Member since:
    07 Jun 2019

    • Time spent:
      72d 47m 19s

  • Total level:
    2,277
    Awards

This?

85b54983ba5f0507ea8500a63b69022e.gif

 

Also, range is more effective on Alora's Kraken, whereas OSRS's Kraken is completely magic.

 

Quoting OSRS wiki 

"Magic is the only reliable way of dealing damage to it, as Ranged attacks are heavily reduced, and Melee cannot be used"


rCjd36m.gif

779858f92372b65448411ebb99ae2454.gif

Community Awards

186389e1c9f184e3f3b56b038179afd0.png

 

Spoiler

Content

467021453b22f2e55b6161e34fc517a3.png

Topic 89500 - My Problem with Staff

Topic 89503 - My Problem with Staff II

Topic 89512 - My Problem with Staff III

Accomplishments

b238e051c524997fa395f7b94120f707.png

17f0b0f3326931f82ad4b16c654cbca8.png

ed4359218fa2f48adc03ffb7aabeb9ce.png

f0db828700bca6a0f649a8675bd8d2ff.png

Spoiler

Game Suggestions

Pet Timeline

4053bef497bbaee8b3db94aec03237ed.png

Spoiler

Posted 21 July 2022 - 01:41 PM #9

Selenagomez

Veteran

Selenagomez
Posts: 534
Likes: 606
Clan: Paragon #FAFO



  • Member since:
    25 Jun 2020

    • Time spent:
      65d 21h 49m 41s

  • Previous username:
    Run IT BACK

  • Total level:
    2,277
    Awards

This?

85b54983ba5f0507ea8500a63b69022e.gif

 

Also, range is more effective on Alora's Kraken, whereas OSRS's Kraken is completely magic.

 

Quoting OSRS wiki 

"Magic is the only reliable way of dealing damage to it, as Ranged attacks are heavily reduced, and Melee cannot be used"

 

On OSRS you do not need to attack the pools anymore to spawn kraken. They made it easier just throw a item at the boss pool and gg. but this is getting out of hand for a suggestion thread so this will be my last comment on here.


Posted Image
Posted Image

Posted 22 July 2022 - 04:42 AM #10

Sagacious
Veteran

Sagacious
Posts: 856
Likes: 1,019
Clan: ICE



  • Member since:
    28 Jun 2018

    • Time spent:
      54d 13h 40m 46s

  • Total level:
    2,277
    Awards

I personally hate the Dusk and Dawn encounter due to the reasons you stated. It just feels slow and unejoyable. I really can't be completely unbiased when it comes to the drop rates because I have the pet and only missing the jar from the log. It is very demotivating to go there to hunt only the jar as it is but such is life of a collection log ocmpletionist. :D

Support!



Posted 25 July 2022 - 05:30 PM #11

Aves
Veteran

Aves
Posts: 298
Likes: 586
Clan: ICE
Location: US


  • Member since:
    20 Aug 2020

    • Time spent:
      34d 18h 22m 27s

  • Total level:
    2,277
    Awards

The prison spec has always been so annoying. This would definitely make GGs a lot less tedious to grind. 

 

Support from me.


Community Awards

Spoiler

Posted 02 August 2022 - 03:48 PM #12

Neuro
Classic

Neuro
Posts: 59
Likes: 116



  • Member since:
    29 Jun 2020

    • Time spent:
      51d 5h 59m

  • Previous username:
    NEUROFUNK

  • Total level:
    2,277
    Awards

SUPPORT Heavily for this one

 

Killing Dusk is so painfully tedious it can get to the point where Dusk's kill times are at least 50% longer than Dawn's


Community Awards

Spoiler

Posted 03 August 2022 - 12:16 PM #13

Omicron

Founder

Omicron
Posts: 1,409
Likes: 13,484



  • Member since:
    18 Jul 2016

    • Time spent:
      420d 16h 25m 13s

  • Total level:
    2,473
    Awards

Your suggestion has been accepted.






0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users


This topic has been visited by 65 user(s)